Google’s right to be forgotten appeal heading to Europe’s top court | TechCrunch

Google’s right to be forgotten appeal heading to Europe’s top court

Posted Jul 19, 2017 by Natasha Lomas (@riptari)

Europe’s ‘right to be forgotten’ ruling, which allows private citizens in the region to make requests that search engines delist incorrect, irrelevant or out of date information returned by an online search for their full name, is set to return to the region’s top court to settle an ongoing dispute between Google and the French data protection agency, CNIL.

The latter has pushed for Google to make these delistings apply globally, i.e. across all web domains, rather than geo-limiting delistings to the person’s home territory (as Google prefers to) — arguing that for Google not to do this offers a trivial workaround to a rule that’s intended to preserve European’s privacy rights.

Google filed an appeal against the CNIL’s order for global delisting in May last year, following a fine of €100,000 handed to it by the regulator for non-compliance.

The court hearing Google’s appeal has now decided to refer certain legal questions relating to European law to the CJEU for a preliminary ruling before coming to a judgement on the case itself.

In a statement the French court said: “[T]he Council of State considers that the scope of this right to dereferencing poses several serious difficulties for the interpretation of European Union law. He therefore stayed the proceedings on the application of Google Inc. and referred several questions to the Court of Justice of the European Union for a preliminary ruling.”

The court adds that the extraterritoriality of the CNIL’s requirement for global delisting “poses a serious difficulty in interpreting the Law of the European Union”.

A spokeswoman for the CNIL declined to comment on today’s development.

She suggested a CJEU judgment could take around a year to be issued based on the court’s current processes.

On the issue of extraterritoriality — i.e. whether Europe’s digital privacy laws should apply outside the region — Google has argued there should be a “balance” between delisting locally vs globally.

Commenting on the court’s referral to the CJEU in a statement, Google’s global privacy counsel, Peter Fleischer, said: “Since 2014, we’ve worked hard to implement the ‘right to be forgotten’ ruling thoughtfully and comprehensively in Europe. For the last 18 months, we’ve been defending the idea that each country should be able to balance freedom of expression and privacy in the way that it chooses, not in the way that another country chooses. We’re doing this because we want to ensure that people have access to content that is legal in their country. We look forward to making our case at the European Court of Justice.”

The CJEU’s original ‘right to be forgotten’ ruling was handed down in May 2014 — at a time when the phrase ‘fake news’ had yet to become standard Internet currency. So while the court decision kicked up a lot of controversy at the time, and the Google of 2014 tried very hard indeed to pass off the notion that its algorithmic ranking of information in search results was equivalent to a library index card system — i.e. an indelible catalogue of truth — the Google of 2017 would likely have a lot more trouble selling such a pitch, given it’s facing far tougher questions about a fresh crop of controversial issues, such as algorithmic bias and how its own search results promote, ehem, fake news…

Whatever you believe regarding the jurisdiction of one region’s digital laws in another region’s territory, happily for society, which is saddled with living with the full force and impact of these dominant tech platforms, the general debate about commercial hierarchies of online information appears to have moved on — and moved rather closer to the, er, actual truth. Let’s call that progress.

Advertisements

Published by societyissinister.com

societyissinister.com

Leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

noahide news

Prophesy unfolding, the beginning of sorrows

Musings from the Chiefio

Techno bits and mind pleasers

Prydain

Thoughts on Anglicanism, Scripture, and the Gospel

Non Possumus

societyissinister.com

The Truth Is From God

YS, by the Quran which decrees, truly, you are one of the Messengers, on a Straight Path, according to the order descended by the All-Mighty, the Most Merciful. In order that you may warn a people whose forefathers were not warned, so they are heedless. Indeed the Conjecture of punishment has proved true against most of them, so they will not believe. Verily! We have put on their necks iron collars reaching to the chins, in such a way that their heads are raised up, and We have put a barrier before them, and a barrier behind them, and then we covered them up so that they cannot see. It is the same to them whether you warn them or you warn them not, they will not believe. You can only warn him who follows the Reminder, and fears the Most Gracious without seeing Him. Bear you to such one the glad tidings of forgiveness, and a generous reward.

Hemp Edification

Hemp can save the planet!

INGVterremoti

l'informazione sui terremoti

Ahrcanum

Conspiracy, HAARP, Earthquakes, Volcano's, Weather Modification, H1N1, Swine Flu, NWO, Politics, and other hedonistic topical articles from The CEO & Czar of The Committee In My Head. Three may keep a secret, if two of them are dead.

Islam Reigns

Providing Information about Various aspects of Islam

Reflect | Deflect | Digest

A matter of faith ...

Giving Dawah to Shia

Defending Sunnah Against The Accusations of Shia

BISES Faith Foundation's Blog

Bangladesh International School (English Section, Riyadh, KSA)'s Islamic Blog

I Seek The Truth

My Lord, Increase me in Knowledge

Reflections of a Sexual Abuse Victim

"Remember Me When You Are In Hell!"

Fiona Barnett

An Australian Experience of Ritual Abuse & Mind Control

Artvoice

Art, Culture, News, and Opinion

Fighting Monarch

A Resistance Site For Victims of CIA, NSA, MI5 and Illuminati Mind Control

wineismylife

the random musings of a museless mind

Brotmanblog: A Family Journey

Adventures in Genealogy

CosmicMind

Dissolving Ordinary Unconsciousness

rapidcyclistwordpresscom

Cycling, breast cancer recovery, bipolar disorder

WEARS WAR on the Lies, Liars & WW2

Author John Wear reveals evidence contradicting the narrative we have been taught about Germany, Japan & the Allies in World War II. WEARS WAR is the battle to bring FAKE HISTORY into accord with the facts.

#SHAKEDOWN

True Crime Analysis, Breakthroughs, Insights & Discussions Hosted by Bestselling Author Nick van der Leek

eladiofernandez

Luz sobre sombras. Café cultural.

Exercise and Health

Exercise, health, nutrition, diet and lifestyle.

Deep Concerns

global politics

justiniandeception

Principles of TRUST-LAW Governance being: Master SERVANT (SLAVERY) arrangement.

On The Minds

Between The Lines

The Real Fresh Start Foundation

Support4CSA/CSE Victims/Survivors exposing frauds/liars/sadistictrolls

The Country Goth Girl

Just a badass country girl living life on my own terms.

IN PLAIN SIGHT NEWS

Keeping Tabs On The Not So Hidden News And The Hidden

Reptilian Dimension

Your source for: reptilian, Jesuit, conspiracy and Illuminati information

Political Vel Craft

Veil Of Politics

bluebrightly

Wanderings & observations

Peuples Observateurs Avant Garde Togolaise et Africaine

Résistance Togolaise, Africaine et Française, En lutte contre les dictatures et les mafias en Afrique

New and Used Car Reviews, Comparisons and News | Driving

The leading online destination for the latest automotive news, reviews, photos and video for Canadians. Driving's team of award-winning journalists publishes original, fresh content in print, online, on smartphone and tablet.

olgacomscandal

Please read these important informations!! Stop Olgacom geo-engineering now >> see the page on the right!!

Zoe Ambler

...I go Bump in the Night

societyissinister.com

societyissinister.com

Soheli Tasnim

my life my time..

The God of Rage

Know the Truth.

HOAXTEAD RESEARCH

Fact-finding to refute the scurrilous allegations, support the Hampstead community and expose the hoaxers

Radio Spada

Radio Spada - Tagliente ma puntuale

HiDeHo CONTROVERSY of Madeleine McCann Wordpress

Not a typical blog - Not OUR opinions - A CRASH COURSE of the Madeleine McCann case based on FACTS from the files with random info, videos and links.

The McCann Case

This is an attempt to unravel the facts & the many varied & changing claims surrounding the death, abduction or dissapearance of Madeleine McCann aged 3, whilst on holiday with her parents and younger siblings in Portugal, on the night of 07-May-2007, to try to establish the truth.

Penarth Daily News

Penarth's on-line daily news service

%d bloggers like this: